Wednesday, March 16, 2011

Of Stars and Bones: Patricio Guzmán's profound NOSTALGIA FOR THE LIGHT


New Yorkers are blessed this week to have two documen-taries as diverse and humbling as Bill Cunningham New York (covered two days ago) and now the latest exploration of history and memory in Chile from Patricio Guzmán, the filmmaker/poet who has given us The Battle of Chile; Chile, Obstinate Memory; and the documen-tary about Salvador Allende (also covered earlier this week).

His new film NOSTALGIA FOR THE LIGHT, which won Best Docu-mentary at last year's European Film Awards, may not actually bring to a close Guzmán's accounting of the ravaging of his birth country by the Pinochet regime (nothing save the filmmaker's own death will shut that door), but it is hard to imagine that he might do anything better, richer or more profound than this new film.

From the metallic sheen of the telescope (below) that opens the movie to the lace napkin and linen tablecloth in the kitchen or the slim, sculpted legs of a wooden chair in the living room that we see soon after -- the objects that begin the film are captured with such attention and love that we feel somehow secure. We're in the Atacama Desert, where the humidity is the lowest of anywhere on our planet and the air is ultra-clear for viewing the stars. Guzmán (shown at left) narrates the film himself, and his soothing, meditative voice, accompanied by a parade of stunning images, tells of the history of this unusual desert (where rain never comes), with its mollusks and meteorites, archeology and (now) astronomy.

The filmmaker speaks first with an astronomer -- a smart, thoughtful fellow who lives and works in the desert -- and who waxes philosophical about everything from the stars to time itself: "Does the present exist?" he asks, after giving us a terrific explanation of why not. "Maybe only in our mind." (So much for that once popular phrase, Be Here Now.) Another man notes that the country of Chile still remains in the grasp of the coup d'etat: "We've hidden away our nearest past, the 19th Century -- and the Indians." He speaks of buried minerals and buried men, as we watch a row of musical spoons waft and sing in the wind and think about what we owe other living humans beings.

A half-hour in, we get the real connection: Near the observatory (above) lies the remains of Chacabuco, the largest concentration camp of the Pinochet regime. We meet a former prisoner from the camp who explains how he and others in a group of prisoners would observe the stars and feel oddly... free. (Until the guards made them stop because they might use those stars to navigate to freedom. As if.)

We learn that the regime buried many of their prisoners here in the surrounding desert. And then, to ensure that the bodies could not be found, identified and the guilty prosecuted, they dug up those corpses, broke them apart and re-buried them. We meet several of the women (below) who now spend their lives digging and searching through the many bones (and bits of bones) for their "disappeared" loved ones. One of these sits in the desert and speaks of finding and then stroking her brothers foot. "We were reuinited. Only then could I take in the fact that he was dead."

We also meet an exiled mother and son, now back in Chile. He's an astronomer, she gives massages to the victims of the torture. Guzmán does not dwell on the atrocities, as we've seen and heard about them previously. Yet through these people and their stories we glimpse quite enough to make this terrible time indelible.

The last story is that of a young female astronomer (above) who could easily stand in for this entire country. Used as a child hostage by the Pinochet regime to get her grandparents to tell the whereabouts of her parents (which they did  in order to save the child's life), she lost both parents and was raised by her grandparents. How the young woman, herself now a mother, has come to terms with all that has happened, how she feels and why, her splendid use of the word "defect," and how, via astronomy and contemplation, she has found her place in the universe -- all this is profoundly important and moving, a privilege to experience.

You will stand up after watching Nostalgia for the Light feeling invigorated and chastened, with the images of the disappeared -- in close-up above, and all together, like some mammoth AIDS quilt made of tiles, below -- an indelible, even welcome presence. Though absent, they are still here.

Many of the people interviewed in the film are not particularly religious, yet their thoughts and ideas stuck me as being as close to the truth about what unites us to each other and to the universe as anything I have yet heard.  If this is not pleasing to the Christian, Jewish and Muslim fundamentalist religions, it is certainly good enough for me. As I hope it will be for you.

Nostalgia for the Light, from Icarus Films, debuts this Friday, March 18, at IFC Center, New York, for an exclusive two-week engagement. For a complete listing of venues -- cities, dates and theaters (14 in the U.S., two in Canada) where you can see this film, click here. Coming from Icarus, of course, there will also, eventually, be a DVD available.

Note: Interested in meeting this wonderful filmmaker? Señor Guzmán will appear in person at IFC Center on Friday, 3/18, and Saturday, 3/19, at the 8:10 shows.

Tuesday, March 15, 2011

Doris Yeung's MOTHERLAND opens at the Quad Cinema in New York. Ouch!

Criticizing a movie like MOTHERLAND -- about a adult daughter, estran-ged from her mother, who suddenly must travel to San Francisco to pick up the pieces when she learns that mom has been murdered -- is more difficult than usual. This is because, according to the press materials, the film is a reaction by the writer/director Doris Yeung to her own mother's violent murder. That's certainly a heavy burden for any filmmaker to bear. And knowing about this makes it more difficult for a critic to approach the film fairly. At least it certainly proved so for TrustMovies. Yet Motherland is, for the most part, a dreadful piece of film-making. Not knowing Ms Yeung nor her work (this is her first film of any kind, full-length or short, narrative or documentary), nor the actual details of her life, TM can only guess that this tyro filmmaker is too close to her material to do it any kind of justice.

Did Ms Yeung, shown at right, try to stay too exacting about the real details, or did she err in the opposite direction by creating a "fiction" tale brimming with money, murder, jealousy and betrayal. (Maybe the real details were just so: a melodramatic hash of M, M, J & B.) Whatever: I can say that what hits the screen starts off bearably, if a little shakily, in Mexico, where our heroine lives happily enough and in very nice quarters until she receives a middle-of-the-night phone call. Once she returns to San Francisco and we meet her friends and relatives, and the plot, as they say, thickens, the movie goes alarmingly downhill. Performances grow increasingly wobbly, as the actors are forced into actions that appear less and less likely or real; the writing degenerates badly (one scene between a cop and our heroine is among the most inane in movie history); even some of the transitions (a visit to the dead mom's apartment) seem almost nonsensical. Somewhere around the middle of this 93-minute film, it hits home that you're attending amateur night at the movies.

Yeung has certainly cast her film with some pros, whose resumes reach down to your knees. This does not help. The beautiful French-Canadian/Chinese actress Françoise Yip (above, whose first theatrical movie was Jackie Chan's Rumble in the Bronx) is wooden, at best.

As Yip's naughty dad, 72-year-old Hong Kong actor Kenneth Tsang (above, who boasts nearly 150 credits) overdoes things considerably.

And Byron Mann (above), as an old friend of the family who turns over so many new leaves you expect him to sprout branches, tends to raise his eyebrows and look happily confused. Well, he's working, right, so what's not to be happy about?

As a filmmaker, Yeung seems to favor extreme close-ups, which are interesting until plot and characters go to pieces. Then those same close-ups have the effect of making us start to snicker. (There's a scene in which the heroine listens to a conversation she's not meant to hear, which can only be occurring because the two men she overhears have zero peripheral vision. She's right there in plain sight, for god's sake! Why don't they see her?) One of the few good things Yeung manages is to make her heroine a lesbian -- without also making a big deal of it. The situation is treated as natural as anything else we see (though we also suspect that it accounts for the rupture between mother and daughter).

The themes the filmmaker addresses are all worthwhile: justice, honor and culture clash: the immigrant experience after arrival in the new land. But to get us to pay attention to these, Yeung has got to do better than slap in some symbolic pigeons (below) and then hand us at the climax a scene so ridiculous, silly and melodramatic that it immediately becomes near-classic camp. Well, there is always next time. Unless perhaps, by telling her story, Ms Yeung has gotten the past out of her system -- which may be enough for her.  If not, and she makes another movie, I promise to watch it with no preconceived notions and a hope for the best.

Meanwhile, Motherland -- not to be confused with that fine documentary of the same name from 2009 -- opens this Friday, March 18, in New York City at the Quad Cinema.

Monday, March 14, 2011

Richard Press' piquant portrait of NY Times photographer Bill Cunningham (who long ago shot TM's daughter "On the Street") puts fashion & fashionistas in their place


The year is young, but for a moving, meaningful documen-tary about a genuine original (in an indus-try that's so faux), look no farther than Bill Cunningham -- the man and the movie about him. A fixture in the fashion field for decades, as well as at The New York Times (and during the early days of Details magazine), Mr. Cunningham is one of the most unusual men to ever grace a major documentary. Richard Press' lovely ode to this little guy and his very big career -- BILL CUNNINGHAM NEW YORK -- is in many ways a model of its kind: It gives us a good amount of the photographer's wonderful work to pour over, while letting us slowly get to know and warm up to this joyful loner, who turns out to be not only smart, talented and, yes, very set in his ways -- but also quite the private person.

So expertly does Mr. Press (at left) show us the man and his work, along with the scoop on why this work is so important to Cunningham (and, hello, to fashion) -- why, for instance, he refused to accept money for his work for Details magazine, and how and why his split with Women's Wear Daily occurred -- that, as private as the photographer is, by the end of the film, we feel that we know him as well as we ought to, given his desire not to share. When, maybe twice during the movie, Press presses his subject for more information, the filmmaker is an absolute gentleman as he goes about it, explaining, "You don't have to answer this if it upsets you."

One of these moments clearly does, if not upset Cunningham (shown above, with his big grin), at least makes it difficult for him to answer. When he finally speaks, the scene is moving and graceful, genuine and caring. And we in the audience actually come away not wanting to know any more because we realize that the knowledge we'll gain -- in this case regarding Cunningham's religion and sexuality -- is not worth the possible pain or disturbance to this kind man. Together, treading a path of honesty tempered with discretion, Press and Cunningham actually make better people out of us viewers.

In any case, what we do learn is plenty. Cunningham, in his work over the past fifty years, keeps showing us fashion -- the real thing, worn by people on the street, rather than the stuff dictated to us by WWD, Anna Wintour (caught in Cunningham's lens, above) and the rest of the rat pack that has been passing itself off as the cognoscenti of true fashion. I'm not saying these people and their magazines are worthless, mind you -- not quite, anyway -- just far too self-important and deluded. All you need do is take a good, hard look at at least half the stuff raved over by these fashionistas, and then compare this with what Mr Cunningham has photographed -- those shoes and the women in them, shown below, for instance -- to understand who and what really matter.

Regarding WWD, it was when that rag used the photographer's work -- which he had shot to demonstrate how people on the street can put together their own wardrobes with a real sense of fashion and understanding of what works -- with copy that stated exactly the opposite, that these "street people" were laughable and had no fashion sense, that the photographed parted ways with WWD forever. The movie shows Cunningham at work on the street, where he draws all his inspiration.  Now 81 (or maybe 82?) the film shows us his 80th birthday celebration at the NY Times), he's still going strong, having been evicted from his long-time living quarters in the Carnegie Hall apartments (those are his filing cabinets full of old negatives, below), but thankfully having been placed elsewhere in decent digs.

We also see the man's fine design sense in the way he organizes his weekly On the Street with the help of his NY Times art director, his time in Paris (both recently and back in the 1950s), and some great photography hints ("Use you camera like a pen -- to take notes!"). There is so much to see and mull over here -- Bill shooting and chatting up the two Houndstooth honeys, below -- that not a minute is wasted, and when the movie ends, you'll have spent some quality time with a fellow who's absolutely unforgettable.

Bill Cunningham New York, another winner from Zeitgeist Films, has its world theatrical premiere this Wednesday, March 16 in NYC's Film Forum. Click here for Film Forum showtimes and tickets -- and here for further playdates (there'll be lots of them) cross country.

*********

Oh- yes: I mentioned in my headline that Cunningham had once photographed my daughter Laura for use in one of his On the Street Sunday fashion half-pages for The New York Times, dated June 3, 1990.  That's she (above, center right), striding with bag in hand. Here's a link to the article itself but -- shoot! -- no pictures in the Times' archive?! (It turns out that the photographer also shot my grand-daughter Marlo at a recent ballet event -- but that one didn't make the cut.)

Sunday, March 13, 2011

DVDebut: Patricio Guzmán returns yet again to SALVADOR ALLENDE


For Chileans of a certain age and leftist political leanings, Salvador Allende is the touchstone and always will be, so long as those people live. Likewise for right-leaning Chileans, Augusto Pinochet is the revered model. The latter's overthrow of Allende's democratically elected government (by the American-backed Chilean military) and the 15-year dictatorship that followed, along with the many missing and murdered dissidents, will remain the singular event/time period of all these lives -- no matter that many of Chile's young people today want to cry "Get over it!" There is no getting over it until all those who lived through these decades lave been laid to rest. For Chile, this time frame occupies a place similar to the disappeared in Argentina or, for the elders of Spain, their Civil War.


The Chilean/
Spanish writer, teacher and filmmaker Patricio Guzmán (shown at left) has amassed quite a body of work involving the Allende/
Pinochet time period. Obsessed (but in a useful manner) is not too strong a word, I think, to describe his connection to this era. His massive, three-part docu-mentary/history The Battle of Chile, together with Chile, Obstinate Memory and The Pinochet Case are probably his best-known films in this country. (The filmmaker's newest work, the award-winning Nostaligia for the Light, opens this coming Friday at IFC Center in New York. I'll have more to say about it later this week.)

About Guzmán's Salvadore Allende, for those not so much informed about this Chileans leader, the documentary should prove a good place to begin. Much shorter (100 minutes) than the four-and one-half-hour-long Battle of Chile, Guzmán still uses a number of shots and scenes from that film in his newer documentary.  Some of these I was thrilled to see again (that indelible sequence of the young man running through the streets, pulling the cart!); others, because I was already aware of them and knew the background, seemed more like filler.

What the documentary offers that no one interested in politics and history will want to pass up is the interview with former U.S. Ambassador Edward Korry that Guzmán weaves through the movie. This give-and-take provides what can only be called an insider's account of the absolute insistence of President Richard Nixon and Henry Kissinger that Allende and his democratic regime be stopped. Initially it seems that Korry might be sorry for the way things turned out ("things" that include Pinochet's reign of terror), but, no. The ex-ambasssador proves utterly unrepentant about the CIA-sponsored coup that overthrew the Chilean government -- using the old fear-of-Russian-Communism as the usual excuse. He even claims that his superiors kept the information about the coup from him at the time.

The other important reason to view this film is the debate Guzmán gives us between former militants from different political parties, as they argue over how and why Allende failed to defend the government in the period leading up to the coup by arming and mobilizing a people's militia as a counterforce to the military -- which was by then firmly controlled by forces who opposed Allende. This is probably the firmest argument for why the regime collapsed, but Guzmán has already made it clear that Allende wanted his government -- which had been democratically elected rather than taking the country by force, as did the Russians in 1917 and Castro in 1950s Cuba -- to above all remain democratic rather than becoming an armed force. This was not possible given the sleazy dealings of the Cuban right, together with those of the USA, and Allende paid for his miscalculation with his own life and those of many of his countrymen.

But would an armed militia -- which I can't imagine would not have led to a civil war, undoubtedly won by Pinochet's forces (supported, of course, by the USA) -- have resulted in any less suffering and death?  What all this says about the possibility of genuine democratic social change without accompanying armed force is not very positive or promising. Is it?

Salvadore Allende, from Icarus Films Home Video, is available for sale and rent this Tuesday, March 15. In English, French and Spanish, with English Subtitles, the DVD Bonus Features include a stills gallery by Chilean photographer Patricio Guzmán Campos, featuring 22 photos of Chile in the 1960s and 1970s and a theatrical trailer for Guzmán's latest film, Nostalgia for the Light.

Saturday, March 12, 2011

The inventive Hungarian Oscar submission: Szabolcs Hajdu's BIBLIOTHÈQUE PASCAL

Keeping up with the best foreign language film submission for the yearly Academy Award's ceremony is getting to be a nearly full-time occupation. But it's worth that time. For every outright bomb (Greece's Dogtooth, that made it practi-cally to the Oscar finish line by using transgressive sex to hook critics into going along for an empty ride) or so-so movie (Mama Gógó from Iceland, Germany's When We Leave), you're likely to come across a splendid film that you wouldn't be seeing otherwise. One such, and the subject of today's post, is Hungary's entry into this year's sweepstakes, BIBLIOTHÈQUE PASCAL. And a more beautiful, ugly, strange yet finally comprehensible movie you'll be hard-pressed to find.

That soon-to-be airtight wetsuit on the poster above (and in one of the stills below) makes for a breathtakingly creepy image and scene, and its use by writer/director (and ofttimes actor) Szabolcs Hajdu, pictured at right, is as shocking as it is bizarre. Part of a very high-end and exceedingly literate brothel at which wealthy clientele have all sorts of wishes fulfilled, the costume and its use allows Hajdu to give vent, I would guess, to some of his more grotesque fantasies. That these come side by side with others of delicious sweetness and light is what makes the movie so memorably odd. And the cinematography by András Nagy -- interior, exterior, natural light or created -- is simply stunning, frame by frame by gorgeous frame.

The story begins with a quietly distraught mother appealing to a social service worker for the return of her daughter, whom she had been left with an aunt of possibly less-than-sterling character. But then no character in this amazing movie approaches sterling, let alone silverplate or brass. You could, if you were so inclined, cal this movie a treatise on how precarious is survival in the Eastern Block -- whether yesterday, today or tomorrow.

And so our heroine Mona (a fine performance from Orsolya Török-Illyés, above, that combines strength and steely beauty in equal doses) begins her explanation to the social worker.

From the first, this seems a phantasmagoric tale of love, jealousy and betrayal, followed by a quick, then an even quicker, change of partners.

Which leads to a night of passion (and more great visuals!) with a very hot, but not long-lasting criminal named Viorel (Andi Vasluianu, below), which leads to the birth of that child.

Men, we quickly learn, are not to be trusted, most of all one's own father, below, who makes a very dirty deal, regarding Mona.

And this takes us to the titular bibliothèque -- a combination of the high-tech and old-fashioned bordello sleaze, the highly literary and torture porn -- that provides some of the most beautiful and creepy scenes in the film.

Hajdu creates an almost constant tension between the gorgeous visuals we love to watch and the subject matter, which grows darker and darker.

The climax -- which involves that wet-suit,

along with a marching band (above) -- culminates in an amazing, funny/sad view of a group people in the street that is one of several shots in the film that I suspect will find a permanent place in my movie memory bank. And the ending? Ohmigod: quiet, sweet, sad, surprising perfection.

But what does all of this mean? Ask that social worker, who takes this wild fantasy and tries to provide it with more "real" details, in order to help Mona. Yet it may be mankind's very ability to spin fairy tales, dark as they are, out of our worst woes that allows us to keep going. Ask Mona, and Mr. Hajdu, who've spun one of the most spectacular of all in this movie that ought to have at least been shortlisted for "Oscar" glory -- and which you really must see.

But how? According to the film's U.S. distributor, GoDigital Media Group, you can click the SAVE button on the film's Netflix site -- and hope that the service gets the DVD and adds it to its streaming facility soon.  Meanwhile, you can rent and download Bibliothèque Pascal via iTunes (and with cinematography this good, I'd pay the extra buck for the high definition version).